I am trying to understand the points here, I guess both you guys are correct (in some sense). When we dyno a car, the dyno gives the power output but do not give information about another entity called "TIME".
I am trying to comprehend the discussion here I could be wrong. Lets take an example of 2 exactly identical cars A and B, only A has a intake hose and large throttle body, vs B is stock, If they are dyno'ed they would give exact same power graphs (may be slightly different because not all cars are same, lets assume they are same hypothetically), but you get the point. This is what 1turbofocus is telling. Both A and B have same peak power numbers at same rpms. (lets assume that is at 5k rpm).
Colossus is telling that the TIME it takes to reach to that power numbers might be different because of the difference in throttle response. Hypothetically if car A has better throttle response because of the intake hose and bigger throttle body, then car A will go to the peak power let say at 5k rpm but it only takes "6sec" and car B will go to the peak power at the same rpm as car A, 5k rpm (cause they are hypothetically identical) but takes "7sec", might have a slight disadvantage on timed race.
The power graph is same but the one car have an advantage over the other, I think same rule applies to other factors such as the weight of the car, if a car is lighter than the other, then the power numbers will not change for both, but the time to reach the peak power will be lower for a lighter car and hence the advantage.
This is what I understood about throttle response, let me know if I am wrong. There is no way to measure the entity called Throttle response, and dyno's couldn't measure time. Is there a way ?