I really like the ST spoiler but I don't dislike the stock one either. The stock spoiler looks ok. To me it's not worth the money to get the ST one. First to purchase it primed and then to paint match to my car. I'd rather invest that money on new tires when I need them instead. On the other hand, if I ever come across an ST spoiler from a junkyard in my color, then I might fork that money on it and swap it out!!