If it was me I would get some vinyl and play around with different settings to see what you want. In such a little area it wouldnt be a pain. It will probably be hard to body match the paint exactly unless its an easy color. Sangria would be hard to match possibly. Might look good in shaded or easy light but from different angles you will notice a difference. Painting would match though.
Personally there would be a large area for me to cover if with 08 or 09 lights, mostly just cause I dont like how far they curve back. I would be hidding all that extra stuff going back lol.