I will swap my headlight bulbs out when I get home. But, I've changed the passenger headlight bulb twice in the past 2 months, and have not seen the passenger side high beam work once.Jason,
Based on your current observations your headlight system is working correctly except that your drivers side high beam is out. As previously posted I recommend that you swap the known good passenger side headlight bulb to the drivers side and drivers bulb to the passengers side and repeat the above observations.
Do you think it could be the Headlight socket failing?