



Ford Focus & General Car Chat Discussion Forum relating to nonspecific Ford Focus models, car purchasing, auto industry news and any car talk.



Thread Tools  Display Modes 
01302013, 09:53 AM  #31  
Focus Enthusiast

Quote:
A year old fit can be sold for almost what new one costs. It's insane. I'm curious what the 3 year depreciation looks like and whether the honda/toyotas do better after the first year. 


Sponsored Links  
Advertisement 
01302013, 10:27 AM  #32  
Focus Fanatic

I suppose I consider midwest to be NE, KS, MO.... OH doesn't really say "midwest" to me, but like its been mentioned, perspective has a lot to do with it.
I'm thinking east coast like, VA, NY, ME.... These are all areas where domestic compacts are very popular from what I've seen.
__________________
2011 SES 5spd #006 >> SR #213 What other people think of me is none of my business. 


01302013, 10:34 AM  #33  
<M>

Quote:
One question I do have which might be answered by the further analysis Jdog913 was referring to. What affect do leases have on the analysis? My impression is that the Cruze and maybe Corolla are leased much more often than the rest. I just remember those $169 mo / $1699 down lease deals on the Cruze a year or so ago. I don't know how the "purchase price" gets reported to the likes of truecar.com with lease deals. I just don't have access to the data necessary to be able to analyze that. 


01302013, 11:34 AM  #34  
Focus Enthusiast

Hi, a handy calculator here, only for the uk http://www.whatcar.com/cardepreciat...ioncalculator
__________________
Mk3 Focus Titanium X, 1.6 Ecoboost 150ps + Bluefin Remap Candy Red Appearance Pack 18" 5 Spoke Alloy Wheels Manual 6speed gearbox,,, 


01302013, 08:11 PM  #35  
Guest

Quote:
Here is few questions to ask yourself. Is the data for each vehicle normally distributed meaning a bell curve? Does the arithmetic mean (Average) equal or to close the median of each data set? Have you calculated the ZScore for high and low values of each data set and make sure the score falls in between 2 and 2? Now the ZScore checks for outliers in the data set. (Really large or small numbers) Outliers can add bias to the data set and take away from the true average. A few variables that I thought of for this data set that can cause outliers are high mileage vehicles, and individuals who ask too much or too little for there vehicle. This can also be seen in the division of mean by the median. The closer it is the number one then the better. All of the statements above relates to probability. Probability is important because if the results are no repeatable then the conclusion that was drawn is not correct. Now I've crunched some numbers that you posted for Tampa, FL. I tried to explain this the best I can but if you have any questions please feel free to ask. I'll try to explain Mean, Median, Standard Deviation and ZScore the best I can. I conclude that the Focus, Cruze and Corolla all have skewed data sets. Meaning that the data set is not normally distributed. This also means that the depreciation value calculated for the Focus, Cruze and Corolla are using non normally distributed data. Lets, look at this more deeply. The normal distribution graphs use a range of car values and see how many cars fall in between that value. If the number is Z on the XAxis this means that <= Z and >(Z1). For example 15 on the XAxis range is <=15 and >14. Same goes for any other number. 2012 Focus Sample Size= 20 Max = $17,900 Min = $12,300 Mean = $15,670 Median = $15,650 Std. Deviation = 1.39 Z Score Min = 2.41 Z Score Max = 1.59 2012 Cruze Sample Size= 20 Max = $20,000 Min = $14,500 Mean = $16,495 Median = $16,900 Std. Deviation = 1.58 Z Score Min = 1.26 Z Score Max = 2.21 2012 Corolla Sample Size= 20 Max = $17,400 Min = $12,900 Mean = $15,7900 Median = $16,000 Std. Deviation = 1.06 Z Score Min =  2.72 Z Score Max = 1.51 2012 Civic Sample Size= 20 Max = $19,000 Min = $15,000 Mean = $17,065 Median = $17,000 Std. Deviation = 1.04 Z Score Min = 1.96 Z Score Max = 1.84 2012 Elantra Sample Size= 20 Max = $17,000 Min = $15,000 Mean = $16,035 Median = $16,000 Std. Deviation = .576 Z Score Min =  1.79 Z Score Max = 1.67 I recommend changing the sample size and taking the middle 20 numbers with respect to the median of the whole data set causing a more normally distributed curve. Then we can make conclusions of the data. When this is done then we will most likely see, * ZScores great than 2 and less than 2 * Means and Medians extremely close (Around 1 when divided) * Bell Shape Curve Quote:
Then I would have to guess you don't know what engineering is about. Industrial Engineers deal with statistics on a regular basis. Other engineering disciplines deal with statistical data analysis. Care to explain how the data is valid? 


01312013, 07:09 AM  #36  
<M>

Quote:
As far as outliers, I limited the mileage of vehicles included in the results to 30,000 so that eliminates any unusually highmileage vehicles. Also, if the first lowest priced vehicle was more than say $500 less than the next few, I ignored it. And if there were 5 listed by the same dealer for the exact same price, I generally only included one of those to reduce the effect of that one seller on the results. Your more traditional methods, in my humble opinion (as an engineer and MBA) would not have increased the accuracy of the results enough to justify the extra work. That’s a basic costbenefit analysis. 


01312013, 10:16 AM  #37  
Focus Enthusiast

Oh gawd, for a minute there I thought I was back in my first year of University taking Quantitative Methods and Anaylsis all over again.......arrrrgggh. Jdog, I don't think anyone on here wants to take an intro Stats class, and Kam did a fine job of giving a "generalized" representation to answer a simple question. If others want real, quantitative numbers to crunch, they can certainly do so, but, this is a auto forum, and no one is going to use Kam's numbers to make a major financial decision here. Its all good, but, if you want to do actual market research, I'm sure there is plently of companies out there that will hire you. LOL
__________________
2012 Focus SEL 5 door 303a w/Lux pkg in KonaBlue 2012 Escape Limited w/park assist 2010 F150 Supercrew XTR 5.4 4x4 2008 Kawasaki Concours 14 (street) 2008 Kawasaki ZX10R (track only) 


02012013, 01:20 AM  #38  
Focus Jr. Enthusiast

IMO the data is good, the analysis well designed, the statistical instruments appropriate for their intended purpose, and the results meaningful. Any discussion about variability, skewness or kurtosis is supurfulous  you don't have to beat the data to death to answer the question. Further analyses of the information would be overkill and likely not alter the relative outcomes significantly. Excellent job kam and thanks for taking the time to share your results! Just my 2 cents worth.



02012013, 02:35 PM  #39  
Focus Enthusiast

Quote:
While your desire for further analysis is admirable, I don't see how you can claim the data is invalid, any less than looking in the paper and seeing a car for sale is not valid. As for the 'what does engineering have to do with it'. I think that comment was more directed at the fact that the rest of us know enough statistics to make up our minds about the validity of the original work. Some data is better than no data, and the work done here is interesting and useful. Nobody is going to use it to build a nuclear weapon, so doing a lot of unreasonable stats on it is a waste of time. I've had lots of arguments with people who 'understand' statistics better than me to know that most of the time, they have lost the basic understanding of what statistics is and how it works. Don't take this the wrong way, but you seem to fall into that category here. What you are looking at is a bunch of data, not a statistical analysis. 


02042013, 01:43 PM  #40  
<M>

Kiplingers Names Focus Best Resale Value in Under $20k Class
To further bolster the results of my backoftheenvelope calculations, Kiplinger's has announced the Focus has the highest resale value of cars under $20k.
http://portal.kiplinger.com/slidesho...013/index.html http://editorial.autos.msn.com/12be...uecars2012#2 It joins the ranks of Mini, Volvo, Infiniti, Audi, etc. in the upper price classes. Hopefully this puts to rest the gripes about resale value. The Focus was also named Best Value in the Under $20k class. Joining the ranks of VW, Toyota, Audi, and Lexus in the upper classes. 



Bookmarks & Social Networks 
Thread Tools  
Display Modes  



