Former 2011 Speed3 w tech pkg owner here.
Good insight from a former MS3 owner, thanks!
Like the OP, I'm starting to consider my next-car purchase. Current plan is to buy a new Focus ST in a few years and keep the SVT as a winter car, but I'm really tempted to get a 07-09 MS3 for a year round DD. It would save a hell of a lot of money over the ST, and I have always had a thing for the Gen-1 MS3. Had a chance to drive the new ST and came away as impressed as I thought I would be, but haven't driven an MS3 yet.
To the OP, St. Louis doesn't get a whole lot of snow in winter does it? I bet a RWD car with a good set of winters, or possibly even all-seasons, may get you by. Also worth noting is that the Focus (and other hatchbacks) obviously offer more interior and cargo space, and while that may not be a necessity in a daily manner, having the ability to occasionally haul a large amount or awkwardly-shaped crap is very valuable. That said, good list! I'd take any one of those cars, (if they were given to me!)
Mine: 2002 Focus SVT: 137k, Sonic Blue, #1654, Moonroof, Winter Pack, Audiophile
Mods: Tom's Tune, Borla, CFM STS, painted Machs, Euro grille
Hers: 2010 Focus SES: 60k, Ebony, Auto, Moon and Tune