There is a lot more to fitting wheels than just the width, also look at backspace and offset.
Then you've also got to determine what tire sizes you'd like to use to keep overall diameter as similar as possible.
My vote would be 17x8 all around, I think it will look better and you'll be able to rotate tires freely.
Feb 2011 Ride of the Month ~ 2011 Hatch Nation Hatch of the Year ~ 2011 Focus Fanatics Ride of the Year!
Hatch Nation #2