|11-08-2013 10:26 AM|
EDIT: What I'm reading says that Ti-VCT eliminates the need for an EGR because exhaust gas temperature control can be done in timing. Sources:   
|11-08-2013 08:37 AM|
RockAuto and FordParts.com tell me otherwise...
EDIT: Although, ShopKey doesn't tell me anything about its existence or whereabouts.
|11-07-2013 09:48 PM|
|11-07-2013 05:48 PM|
One point is EGR.. The little devil EGR usually ruins engine braking.
Most manual transmission cars in my recent past have needed to block the EGR valve in order to get ANY engine braking..
I wonder if the Mk3 setup is shutting the EGR so there really IS some engine braking.
In my manual 2012 if I am using cruise control on a long downhill (Here we have a long hill going up to the local water divide on I94 from Milw to Waukesha) with cruise on.. the car does maintain the speed limit.
In neutral on the same downhill the car gains over ten mph.
|11-06-2013 11:04 PM|
|11-06-2013 10:28 PM|
|RetAFEng||I agree with Roman5.8 on his description of the DCT. Yes it will downshift while going downhill and living in a mountainous area, Vancouver Island, I like it. Going down mountain passes I deselect cc and go to S and manually control the gear selection. While following other vehicles down the passes with most on them hard on the brakes coming to curves I drop one or two gears and normally don't have to touch the brakes. Yes the engine revs up, but this engine is redlined over 6000 rpm. My previous vehicle an Escape will a TC type auto would also downshift going downhill on a long grade with cc on. It would do much faster if the downhill control button was depressed. Some of us are much more automatic dependant as we have aged and our knees are shot. Just loved that six speed manual tranny in my old HD 5.9 diesel pickup, but it could not engine brake going downhill without the exhaust engine break activated. Happy Cruising.|
|11-05-2013 02:17 PM|
|JPopNC||Personally I never run CC while in Sport mode, that is reserved for spirited driving, especially on the twisties. Cruise is reserved for highway with the car set to Drive.|
|11-04-2013 06:33 PM|
That was mostly just jest. I prefer a manual, but that's just because I prefer it! Some prefer an automatic.
For the sake of argument though; most of those cars are not automatics; they are automated manuals. Pedantic I know, but, there's an important difference and that's in the clutch. The 'slushbox' term, as you probably know, comes from the torque converter. And I know you know how they work (judging by your knowledgeable posts elsewhere) but for the benefit of others reading, basically (put very simply), it's pumping fluid across two turbines. One attached to the engine, the other to the transmission. The end result is reduced power transfer to the transmission, 'softer' shifting and performance, and other disadvantages. Those 'slushbox' automatics are still popular among drag racers in 2 and 3 speed variations because at WOT some of the disadvantages are minimized and the lack of a need to shift is handy. (Though top fuel dragsters only have one gear, and use a series of clutches!). Torque converters also have a huge disadvantage in engine braking. The transmission needs to be in a low lower 'gear' in order for engine braking to take effect. That's why you can take your foot off the gas and coast with an automatic (though an automated manual may mimick that by releasing the clutch during coasting). That was the intent of what I was saying, most true automatics do not do any real engine braking with cruise control because they are at a disadvantage there. An automated manual though, might.
A clutch connects nearly all of the power to the engine. Take advancements in clutch technology, computer technology, and transmissions, and you can take a standard manual transmission and connect it with a computer controlled clutch for fantastic performance. (There's a 'hybrid' variation of this in a lot of big rigs, where the driver selects the appropriate gear to start with and the clutch pedal is used when stopped and to take off from a stop, but is no longer needed once moving; the computer takes over shifting and the clutch functions).
No doubt that dual-clutch 'automated manuals' are the pinnacle of performance when done right. Though they are very different. This thread is further evidence of that. People not expecting it to behave like it does; because it behaves a lot more like a manual, because it is! The Ford DCT, for example, is a 6 speed manual transmission. It is! The difference is between the transmission and the engine; what makes it an 'automatic' is the automated dual-clutch system. (Okay, there are some internal changes if you get really technical, but the idea is the same).
As for MY preference, I won't notice 1mpg difference, and sometimes performance arguments get silly. Half a second on 0-60? A couple mph in top speed? Ultimately, those things are useless. Kind of like guys arguing who has the highest top speed. Aside from an oval NASCAR track, even a race car on a track rarely sees it's top speed. In fact, much of the track is done below 100mph!
For me, it comes down to fun to drive. I don't care if a car can do 160, 180, or 200. That's not where the fun is. The fun is in the handling and the 0-60 acceleration. The fun is also being in control of the car and having the fun of a manual transmission (which isn't for everyone, some prefer an automatic). After all, it's a focus. There are much faster cars for similar, or a little bit more money. Or, heck, you can get a used low mileage Mustang GT for under $20k. But no reason not to have something that is fun to drive, and reliable! The manual transmission makes that more of a reality, IMO. Plus, automated manuals and slushbox automatics alike are generally less reliable than a manual. A manual transmission has less parts and the parts are simple!
Kudos to Ford though. I think the DCT is awesome. I do think Ford should educate the customers though. Like, calling it an automated manual in the book instead of an automatic. Elsewhere they call it that, but I think they do a disservice telling customers they have an automatic transmission; because they really don't, and they should be educated in how it will behave differently than the automatics they are used to. They could also be educated on how to get the most out of it!
I test drove one with a DCT (nothing with a manual in stock). It was a great transmission! But I still prefer a manual.
|11-04-2013 05:56 PM|
I used to think automatic transmission = slushbox.
These days there are a number of cars with an optional automatic outperforming a manual.
Also keep in mind that a GT-R (one example of many) is only available with an automatic.
|11-04-2013 05:30 PM|
|This thread has more than 10 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.|