I picked up my set of WeatherTechs today. I decided that it was worth the money to buy a set seeing as my normal winter mats seem to go missing every year and the fits-all-makes never seem to fit right in my car.
I checked the Huskey Liners but decided that the WeatherTechs gritty texture looks nicer. I might keep them in all year seeing as they don't really look out of place. I bought the front set only seeing as its rare I have anybody in the back seat. $130 (CDN$) all in, including shipping and took about 5 business days to ship.