To be honest, if I'm only getting a free car and nothing else changes, I would choose a Focus ST. It's simple (ignoring all the tech crap in the interior), fast, fun, handles well (hopefully), and most importantly, is practical. I have no use for a sports car and can't afford keeping something like a Ferrari running. All I need is something fun on the weekends but can also work during the weekdays.
Hatch Nation #13 : Rally Revolution #13 : ROTM Jan '13
It's Bryan, not Brian
RSVT-170 Build in Progress
Derusting Rusty Build in Progress